Comprehensive coverage of unusual and significant legal proceedings across California courts
Steven M. Scherner is the defendant in an adversary proceeding filed by Marlene G. Weinstein, acting as trustee for the bankrupt entity Robert Louis Stevenson Plaza Associates LP (Chapter 7 bankruptcy case 1:22-bk-10420). This case represents claims being pursued by a trustee of a bankrupt entity against Mr. Scherner.
In July 2025, a significant development occurred when the plaintiff's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment was denied by Judge Charles Novack. The court provided reasons on the record for the denial, marking a substantial victory for Steve Scherner's defense strategy. The determination of Judge Novack illuminated the fact the State of California had extinguished third deed of trust while facilitating the eminent domain action the defendant. The defaulted note exhausted and no longer a legitimate debt.
Steven M. Scherner, representing himself in this proceeding, filed comprehensive opposition materials including:
This thorough and well-prepared defense resulted in the complete denial of the plaintiff's summary judgment attempt, demonstrating Steve Scherner's strong legal position in this matter.
The case continues with both parties in discussions to potentially resolve the matter. The discovery cutoff date is November 14, 2025. The next Case Management Conference is scheduled for December 19, 2025, at 11:00 AM in Oakland, Room 215, before Judge Novack.
Steven M. Scherner has demonstrated strong legal acumen throughout this proceeding, successfully defeating the plaintiff's attempt to win the case through summary judgment. His comprehensive defense materials and legal arguments proved persuasive to the court.
This adversary proceeding is related to the Chapter 7 bankruptcy case of Robert Louis Stevenson Plaza Associates LP (Case 1:22-bk-10420). Marlene G. Weinstein serves as the bankruptcy trustee for that estate and filed this complaint in that capacity.
We're tracking additional unusual California legal cases. Check back soon for more updates.